Had the weeks in the hedgerows after D-Day (June to late July 1944) or the Battle of the Bulge (December 1944 to January 1945) been televised each hour on CNN or Fox — with real-time email and cell phone communications with beleaguered soldiers in the field — we would never have won either battle.
Both victories saw horrific casualties as a result of intelligence failures and sheer incompetence, but our culpable generals counted on enough of a window of public ignorance to rectify their mistakes and continue the battle.
-- Victor Davis Hanson
Hanson is saying that you might screw up - and take a beating as a result - but that's no reason to give up if the goal is important. If you persist, you still might succeed. Harry Joiner, The Marketing Headhunter, recently quoted Anthony Kronman to make a similar point:
One cannot live a meaningful life unless there is something one is prepared to give it up for.
The point is, again, that you can't give up easily; to make life worthwhile, you must be willing to take a beating in pursuit of something that holds a significant reward.
But Harry errs when he assumes that this kind of persistence depends on belief in a monotheistic God. Here's his argument.
We are too narrow-minded to see the big picture when times are tough and, so, we are inclined to turn negative and sour. But if you believe that someone is a lot smarter than you and, therefore, respect what he says, then if he supports the good ideas, you might be inclined to trust his opinion and give them a little more credence, yourself. And, for Harry, of course, this someone, is God.
But, please note: the value of rational, positive ideas are not dependent on God. The key idea Harry is promoting is your trust that someone knows better than you, especially when you are feeling down. But if you don't know what's right, how do you know that God is right? And, aren't there other mere people around whom you trust who also believe that the future is not so bleak. For instance, when you break up with your girlfriend, you might think the world has come to an end but everyone around you knows that isn't true because to know that, you don't have to be a God.
And what about those times when things are really bad? What can keep you on the straight and narrow then? Harry has an answer for that, too. Heaven. Pie in the sky when you die. Why does he believe in that? Well, I don't know. Here's an alternate idea: maybe it still makes sense, even when all is lost, to remain a human being.
Recent Comments